Leading to Care – Boards do not need to wait for Francis

18 January 2013

By Janet Dawson and Sally Bassett

As we wait for the second Francis report into care failings in Mid Staffordshire, the question has to be asked, given we already know much of what is needed to drive improvements, why are so many healthcare providers waiting?

Setting a responsive regulatory environment that ensures quality of care for patients will be critical for the longer term future of the NHS.  At PwC we’re working with people across the health service in 2013 to debate what the NHS will look like in ten years’ time – NHS at 75, including the key role regulation will play in shaping our future health service.

While regulators and legislators need to wait for the detail of the Francis’ proposals, boards and leaders of healthcare providers should be acting now.  

Will the upshot of the Francis report mean better regulation – or just more regulation?
More regulation sometimes runs the risk of increasing constraints on people using their judgement on how care can be improved.

Regardless of the regulatory obligations which exist, boards have a responsibility for ensuring that the organisation doesn’t become disproportionately focused on meeting those requirements.  Where a board fails to do this, there is a danger that the real purpose and values of the organisation – to provide care which is patient centred, safe and delivered with compassion – become ‘squeezed out’ by a focus on ‘survival’ and regulatory compliance.

But this will be part of a greater cultural change that trust boards need to spearhead, making sure that the purpose of the organisation and the aims and incentives of the staff are aligned.

Boards should be aware of their critical role in influencing and shaping an organisational culture in which the care of each patient is at the centre of decision making at all levels.  Boards should try to:

  • Humanise decisions by looking at the ethical dimensions - are all decisions the Board makes explicitly evaluated against the impact that it will have on patients?
  • Build the capacity of non-executive directors to fulfil their role of challenging the organisation, and identifying where executive decision making may be conflicted between survival or compliance, and patient interest.
  • Recognise and celebrate people for doing the right thing, not just for meeting targets or budgets.

Above all boards need to remember that how they behave impacts on patients on the front line. Boards, and especially non-executive directors, should be confident in their answers to each of these questions:

  • Are the behaviours exhibited by the leaders in your organisation, and the way you treat staff, 100% consistent with the organisation's professed values?
  • When employees read your annual report, do they see a Trust they recognise?
  • What aspects of your Trust would you worry about being on the front pages of the newspaper?
  • Would you feel completely happy if an elderly member of your family was admitted to your hospital as an emergency over the weekend?

Any hesitation means boards need to act now, and not wait for the next inquiry or recommendation.

A version of this blog first appeared in the HSJ.

To read more about the NHS at75 programme go to www.pwc.co.uk/nhs75


Sally Bassett: Email  |  Tel: 020 7213 5313



Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated and will not appear until the author has approved them.